Ben,
My only point was that winterhunter and Carver must have already been acquainted BEFORE the seminar. I don't doubt that Carver (or winterhunter representing Carver) was asked to be a vendor. I also think it's great that Carver donated some calls. I just don't get why this whole mess unfolded the way it did, with a post that has long since been deleted, in which winterhunter said he 'found these great calls at the seminar'. He didn't find them there. He was already acquainted with them at that point. Why not just come out and say up front: 'Check out my great calls'.
I also feel as Tom stated that this thread should stop in the interest of the PPHA, but as soon as he said that greywoof joins as a new member to the site and has to respond.
I'd suggest that this thread be locked. If you or Tom wants to throw in the 'last word', that would be great. Then lock the thread.